Testing Croquet Balls
Since originally writing this article the Croquet Association (CA) has produced a specification for croquet balls. It does not however go anything like far enough to tie down the parameters of the balls. Be aware that the specification for Championship balls is tighter than that for balls for general play. The tournament specifications are set on a country-by-country basis.
1). The main specifications concerning croquet balls for general play are:
2). These are modified for tournament play in the CA's domain via the Tournament Regulations:
3). Finally for championship approval balls must satisfy the constraints published by the CA Equipment Committee:
The variation of some of these parameters with temperature is of considerable interest but is not specified. Other non-specified parameters are also important as they affect the playing characteristics:
To paraphrase; no one wants a smooth soft ball with bias which does not roll like a standard ball and warms up unlike the others if left in the sun but not the same every time!
When reviewing a manufacturer's set of balls, all the balls of a series must be tested individually, i.e. it is not sufficient just to test all the primary colours if secondary are also going to be sold. The pigments used to produce a particular colour may degrade the properties.
The following equipment is recommended for testing balls:
Now for the novel bits ...
To put you out of your suspense the aquarium serves two purposes - it allows the balls to be heated to a known temperature - they can be sunk in the water and left to warm to the water temperature. They then can be removed and either bounce tested or have their dimensions checked. Secondly by making a concentrated salt solution the balls can be made to float. This allows their centre of mass to be checked (Measuring Bias in Croquet Balls by Floatation).
The coefficient of restitution is the ratio of the final velocity to the initial velocity. For croquet balls, a ball is dropped from a known height (60") onto the horizontal steel plate and its rebound height is recorded. To satisfy the regulations it must rebound between 30-45". The rebound heights of a set of balls to be used in a game must not differ by more than 3 inches. For such a drop test the coefficient of restitution is given by: COR = sqrt(rebound height/drop height). For the acceptable rebound values this is a COR range of 0.707 - 0.866.
A number of drops is required on each ball to average out variations. Ideally the bounce characteristics should be recorded at a number of temperatures. If the balls have been brought from say a car boot or club hut to the test site they should be left for a considerable time to equilibrate to the ambient temperature. The temperature of the ball should be noted when the readings are made.
The method of measuring the bounce to date has been to put 6 chalk crosses or other marks on the surface of the ball where three orthogonal axes centred on the ball's centre emerge from the ball. These are numbered and the ball is dropped onto the steel plate with each one of these uppermost in turn. Provided that the ball is released without imposing rotation it should ensure that a different part of the ball is sampled on each drop. The average of the rebound heights is taken. Testing balls is best done by two people - one to drop and record the results and the other to estimate the rebound height.
Measuring points. A small point, if a ball is dropped 60", then all measurements should be made to the bottom of the ball from the surface of the steel plate. If someone is watching how high a ball rises they will see the measurement to the top of the ball most easily and then the diameter of the ball must be subtracted from this value.
Release methods. Generally the ball is held in the fingers
and released. With practice the ball can be dropped with little rotation. For
a permanent test site a more reproducible method may be devised but the precision
of the rebound measurement, which is likely to be modest, should be considered
before investing too much effort.
Rebound measurement. The trusty eye of the beholder is the usual detector. Care must be take to avoid parallax - e.g. squinting at an angle. The viewer must have their eye at approximately the rebound height so they may sight horizontally to the scale behind the ball. Again there is scope for using video recorders and the like, but it seems a trifle sophisticated. A good way to avoid parallax is to place a mirror by the scale behind the ball and, by moving your eye, attempt to get the ball and its image coincident when making the reading.
Note that we cannot presume that the coefficient of restitution is indepenent of force (drop height). Thus if the ball rebounds 60% of the drop height at 60" drop height you cannot expect the same percentage if it is dropped from 20" or 80". Similarly most materials become less bouncy as they get warmer. Prof. Alan Pidcock reports that the coefficient of restitution did not change for drop heights lower than 60"
The bounce test equates to hitting a ball moderately softly. If all the potential energy of the ball at 60" was converted to kinetic energy it would equate to a ball travelling at ~5.5 m.s-1. As the ball only rebounds to ~2/3 this height, 1/3 of the energy is lost in the bounce thus 4.49 m.s-1 is the velocity of the ball. (Energy is proportional to the square of the velocity). As an indication if a ball was hit it this rate across the width of the croquet lawn (assuming no losses) it would take ~5.8 seconds to cross - quite slow.
Temperature range. Croquet is played throughout the year and all over the globe. The temperature range for testing balls is not stated. The range 0º-30ºC would cover most ambient temperatures in which croquet is played, although not necessarily cover the temperatures that the balls reach - a dark ball in the sun will heat up above ambient (Solar Heating of Croquet Balls).
Quick calculations indicate that the temperature effect on the dimensions of the ball is minimal. Most plastics expand by a factor of 1/1000th per degree Celsius; hence the diameter of a croquet ball would change by a little more than 1/4 mm for a 30ºC change. It is the effect on the coefficient of restitution which is probably the most significant. Plastics also become more pliant as they get warmer and a rubbery surface may grip hoop uprights more.
The size of balls is most easily verified with pass/no-pass ball gauges. These are normally a pair metal plates with an accurately machined hole in them. One hole is the minimum permitted diameter and the other the maximum. For these gauges to be accurate you should look for thick plates (e.g. 4mm) with at least 1/2" of metal around the outside of the hole. If there is less metal around the hole it is likely that the metal will have deformed when cut and the hole ends up non-circular. For measurement of ball diameters a plate with a wedge-shaped hole in it can be used. The Laws state "A ball must be 3 5/8" inches, plus or minus 1/32 inch, in diameter"
Obviously the test ball should pass through the maximum gauge and not through the minimum.
What is the diameter of a croquet ball? When the surface is textured where do you measure to - the ball could have dimples like a golf ball or spines like a hedgehog?
The roundness is a measure of the deviation from being a perfect sphere. The constraints for roundness are not part of the Laws but appear in the Croquet Association's Tournament Regulations.
There is a possible confusion about the regulations for ball size and roundness. A ball may be as small as 3 19/32" under the size regulation and be a perfect sphere apart from a hollow an extra 1/16" deep. Is this ball acceptable? Perhaps the sensible interpretation is that 'within the absolute limits of size the roundness is 3 5/8" ± 1/32"'.
Given the above interpretation the same gauges as were used to check for basic size can also be used for the roundness test. The ball is presented to the gauges in all orientations and still should satisfy the pass/no-pass test.
A ball may be perfectly spherical but have an uneven distribution of weight within its bulk. This will cause it to deviate from a straight path like a bowls ball. The centre of mass can be found by floating the ball and seeing if it has a marked preference for settling in one orientation. (See the article by Richard Le Maitre).
One problem is to float the ball. A croquet ball will sink in water, its density should be 1.1089 g.cm-3, water is 1.00g.cm-3. You need a denser medium. Calculations indicate that you would need a 15% by weight salt solution. That can be prepared by dissolving ~166g of salt per litre of water at 20ºC (unchecked!). Add more salt to increase the floatation, or water to reduce it. The degree of bias can be measured by attaching a weight to the surface of the ball until the bias is countered. For really sensitive measurements it has been suggested that some surfactant (detergent) should be added to the brine to lower the surface tension. Reports indicate that some balls require as much as a 5g weight. See recent article (2008).
Spheres of the same size and mass (weight) can roll in completely different ways. As an example if a solid ball and a hollow ball, which is composed of a heavy shell, are rolled down a slope then the solid ball will travel down the slope faster. Balls can be tested against a 'standard ' ball or the time taken to roll down the slope measured. Although you may be able to demonstrate that the ball has different rotational properties there are no specifications that must be met.
The older Jaques Eclipse balls were essentially solid and some of the newer 'solid' plastic ones have a void in the middle. The size of the void is around the size of a grape (see picture of broken striped ball).
Milling patterns. The Laws say nothing about the surface appearance of balls, but they are addressed in the CA's ball specification. The specification is only applicable in the domain of the CA, but is not 'hooked' from the Laws, it just exists. Balls could be as smooth as ball bearings or prickly like hedgehogs. The rougher a ball then the more 'pull' is experienced and, after being struck the sooner it stops skidding and starts to roll on the grass. These are significant effects in the game. There are two main problems; firstly specifying a surface finish and secondly, coping with the inevitable wear on a ball. Unless a standard is defined any surface finish is currently acceptable.
A smooth or dimpled croquet ball (like a golf ball) would be least susceptible to wear. The current design where the ball is covered in tiny pyramids is probably the worst design! A dimpled surface also would not allow the 'meshing' of balls which is thought to contribute to pull.
Surface properties. A second consideration is the hardness and friction of the surface material - it could be like steel or soft and gripping like synthetic rubber. Again there is no standard. The old Jaques Eclipse ball used a cork/rubber composite core that gave the ball its bounce with a thin hard shell giving durability and allowing a surface finish. The modern plastic balls appear to use a single compound to supply the bounce and wear characteristics. Most players notice differences when doing cut rushes or when the ball catches the hoop uprights.
No one wants a ball which takes permanent deformations readily, or splits. The outer shell (or bulk if appropriate) should not take nicks if they are hit by the edge of a mallet or hit a sharp object off the court. The test of durability is probably a practical one - does it last a season or two!
The heating effect of sunlight when a ball is left out in the sun has often been referred to but not measured. You can plainly feel a higher surface temperature on a black ball than on a yellow ball which has been in the full sun. The ability of a ball to absorb heat (its heat capacity) will determine how quickly it gains or loses heat. These measurements are peripheral to the effects of temperature on the other physical properties as if the bounce does not change with temperature then there is no need to worry about the temperature. Small thermocouples placed at the centre of the ball and at its periphery would allow this effect to be monitored.
Most plastic compounds degrade with time due to slow chemical reaction and
exposure to light and air. Consequently one would want to test whether the
properties of a croquet ball change with time. It has been suggested that early
Barlow balls are less bouncy as they get older. A re-test of the balls after
a year or so would be needed to determine whether the properties are changing.
Density is mass over volume. Volume is 4/3 pi r^3=4/3.p.r3
Miniumum density = Largest and lightest sphere = 446.90625/419.3797
= 1.065636 g.cm-3
Thus the density can vary by ~8%
The main equation is Energy (E) is a half the Mass (m) times the square of the Velocity (v): E=1/2.m.v2
As an example for a ball dropped 60" on to a steel plate. The Potential Energy, Ev is given by the mass times the height (h) times the standard gravity constant (g): Ev=m.g.h
1"=.0245 meters, hence h = 60"= 1.524 meters
The velocity of the ball when it hits the plate is hence: v=sqrt (2 * 9.806 * 1.524)= 5.47 m.s-1
The table below, reproduced from another article, indicates some typical ball velocities compared to lawn speeds:
The table relates:
The following were measured by Stan Hall of Australia - see accompanying article.
Coefficient of Sliding Friction, ms
fairly fast lawn (normal, cut to 6mm)=0.48
fast lawn (cut to 4mm)=0.055
The following were measured by Stan Hall of Australia - see accompanying article.
Mallet - Ball contact times
Single ball strokes=~1ms
Ball - Ball contact times
An approximate take-home message is that a rise in temperature of:
Geoff Young adds:
... having bought ball gauges and borrowed a set of feelers, I checked all of all eight sets of balls. I used the moulded spots as axial markers. All balls in all sets turned out to be pretty identical in size and shape, each having one axis about ten thou different from the other two. As the 'legality' criterion allows about 31 thou there was no technical fault. The crescents of clearance weren't easy to distinguish by eye.
Rodger Lane adds:
Testing balls in hoops both in the early morning and in the heat of the day shows that Dawsons expand by about 12 thou when the temperature on the lawns changes from 15 to 30 deg C. Data based on 2 sets of first colours.
Ian Plummer adds:
Single Dawson balls selected for the Macrobertson Shield in 2010 showed diameter variations of about 1/50th".
All rights reserved © 2000-2018